In a recent episode of The Burden, a true crime podcast, Scarcella made shocking remarks. He boldly stated that he would have taken the same course of action as “Nicky Black,” also known as Nicholas Grancio, who is a captain in the Colombo crime family.
Scarcella, despite his relation to Grancio, was tasked with the case and unfortunately, he did not succeed in making any arrests.
Brooklyn Man Exonerated after 14 Years in Prison in Yet Another Case Investigated by Corrupt NYPD Detective
A Brooklyn man has been exonerated after spending 14 years behind bars for a crime he did not commit. This wrongful conviction was the result of an investigation conducted by a corrupt NYPD detective, adding to a growing list of cases tainted by the officer’s misconduct.
The exoneration comes as a result of the ongoing efforts of the Innocence Project, a non-profit organization dedicated to exonerating wrongfully convicted individuals. With the help of DNA evidence and a reinvestigation into the case, they were able to uncover the truth and secure the release of the innocent man.
This case highlights the devastating impact of police misconduct on the lives of innocent people. The actions of this detective not only robbed an innocent man of his freedom but also undermined the trust and integrity of the criminal justice system. It serves as a reminder that the fight for justice and accountability within law enforcement is far from over.
In recent years, there has been an increasing awareness of the prevalence of wrongful convictions and the role that police misconduct plays in these cases. This has led to calls for greater transparency and accountability within law enforcement agencies. It is crucial that steps are taken to prevent and address misconduct, ensuring that innocent individuals are not wrongfully convicted.
The wrongful conviction of this Brooklyn man serves as a stark reminder of the importance of a fair and unbiased criminal justice system. It is a tragic example of the devastating consequences that can arise when those entrusted with upholding the law abuse their power. As we continue to strive for justice, it is essential that we hold law enforcement accountable and work towards a system that is truly just for all.
During the interview, Scarcella made a remark about his uncle being a suspect in the murder investigation at his own house. According to Scarcella, his uncle stated that the victim was not a good kid.
When asked about whether he had inquired with his uncle about the murder of Aratico, Scarcella responded, “I can’t recall, maybe I prefer not to remember. I was determined to exhaust all possibilities in the case, and if Nicky was responsible for the killing, I would have had to arrest him. I don’t think Nicky would have objected to that.”
According to the statement provided, the motive behind the incident involving Aratico was the alleged act of turning Nicky’s daughter onto drugs. Although there was no concrete evidence to support this claim, it was believed to be the underlying reason for the altercation.
According to Scarcella, the NYPD’s internal affairs bureau conducted an investigation into the case, and he asserts that he emerged from it unscathed and without any wrongdoing.
The internal report of the Burden was reviewed by the producers, which included Steve Fishman, a veteran journalist and producer. However, they noticed that some crucial details were missing from the report.
According to Scarcella, he was completely unaware of his uncle’s involvement in organized crime.
Brooklyn man exonerated in 1995 murder case connected to former NYPD Detective Louis Scarcella found guilty in new trial
In the end, it was not surprising that no one was arrested, especially considering Scarcella’s strong sympathy towards his uncle.
Scarcella, speaking on the podcast, explained that they had coined the phrase “public service murder,” which accurately described the situation at hand.
When questioned about whether the killing of Aratico could be considered a “public service murder,” Scarcella attempted to retract his statement.
“I have no intention of disrespecting his family or him. However, when it comes to Nicky Black, I believe he carried that sentiment. He probably believed that he deserved to die,” he acknowledged.
Later in the episode, Scarcella shares that he gained a new perspective by seeing things from his uncle’s point of view.
He says that if his daughter had been addicted to drugs, he would have likely done the same thing and turned himself in.
Scarcella expresses his difficulty in labeling his uncle as a murderer, as his uncle, Graciano, was fatally shot in a mob killing in 1992.
Scarcella complained, “Alright, he was a murderer. Are you happy? It was difficult to do.”
During his prime in the 1980s and 90s, Scarcella earned a reputation as a legendary figure within the NYPD. Affectionately referred to as “The Closer,” he had a remarkable talent for obtaining confessions that no one else could. Scarcella was often seen with a cigar in hand, adding to his mystique and cementing his status as a formidable force within the department.
Throughout his career, he successfully resolved a minimum of 175 cases and provided invaluable assistance in an equal number of instances.
But in 2013, people started coming forward as witnesses to question his record, prompting the Brooklyn District Attorney’s Office to initiate a review of his case history.
The DA’s Conviction Review Unit has overturned 37 convictions connected to Scarcella since 2014.
Steven Ruffin, 45, spent 14 years in jail for a murder he didn’t commit. However, his case was recently overturned, making him the latest of eighteen individuals whose convictions have been reversed.
New York City has had to compensate over $110 million in settlements to more than a dozen individuals who were unjustly incarcerated.
